His Dark Materials, BBC One, episode 3 review ★★★★★
In episode 3, Lyra (Dafne Keen) is thrown into the back of a van and promptly rescued by Gyptians. Meanwhile, Mrs Coulter (Ruth Wilson) is aggressively intent on finding her
James Cosmo and Dafne Keen in His Dark Materials, BBC One
Part
of the brilliance of Philip Pullman's His Dark Materials trilogy is his talent to take the most intellectual, spiritual, and philosophical inquiries —
questions that have burdened humanity for millennia — and morph them into edible,
delicious pieces. More than that, Pullman ensures that even a child can
comprehend these mature concepts.
Likewise, every episode of Jack Thorne’s BBC adaptation treads that ponderous territory, without severing these concepts to gratify a mainstream audience (like the 2007 film version did).
Mrs Coulter (Ruth Wilson) upturns Jordan College, seeking its heretical manuscripts
In episode three, Mrs Coulter (Ruth Wilson) and the religious Magisterium ambush Jordan College following Lyra’s escape. Coulter emphasises: ‘Find me something that is heretical or illegal,’ like they’re one and the same — free thought attacked and suppressed in favour of the established religious dogma.
Members of the said Magisterium walk and talk like devoted monks mixed with suited G-Men, making them ideal as evil henchmen. The true scale of their evil, happening in the dark and perilous north, hasn’t yet been revealed; but judging by Coulter's increased venom, it won't be lollipops and sunshine for her Gobbled children. Wilson continues to perform like a terrifying, primal creature — to the extent that her horrible golden monkey daemon acts more human than she does.
The theme of the importance of truth and free-thinking flows through the veins of this episode; it’s effectively the lifeblood of the whole series. At the start, Lyra (Dafne Keen) wakes up in the back of a van — caught like a netted fish — before being rescued by Tony Costa (Daniel Frogson), who takes her to his fellow Gyptians.
Lyra (Dafne Keen) escapes with the Gyptians
In their nearby boat-homes, she learns more about the alethiometer, the golden compass that The Master (Clarke Peters) claimed ‘tells the truth’. The truth is a valuable commodity in this world of theocratic control and, though conceived before the eponymous fake news era, can't help but connect with the present state of the world.
As even more revelations befall Lyra, she has some genuinely touching discussions with Farder Coram (James Cosmo) about the nature of daemons. With wonderful, poetic confidence, Thorne’s dialogue delves into the psychological and metaphysical upshots involved in growing up. For a series named after a line in John Milton’s epic poem Paradise Lost, this only feels appropriate.
More than that, His Dark Materials is poetry and philosophy wrapped in the thrills and tears of an immersive fantasy story; an epic in its own right. This show gets better week by week, and this critic never wants it to end.
His Dark Materials continues Sundays at 8pm on BBC One
Likewise, every episode of Jack Thorne’s BBC adaptation treads that ponderous territory, without severing these concepts to gratify a mainstream audience (like the 2007 film version did).
Mrs Coulter (Ruth Wilson) upturns Jordan College, seeking its heretical manuscripts
In episode three, Mrs Coulter (Ruth Wilson) and the religious Magisterium ambush Jordan College following Lyra’s escape. Coulter emphasises: ‘Find me something that is heretical or illegal,’ like they’re one and the same — free thought attacked and suppressed in favour of the established religious dogma.
Members of the said Magisterium walk and talk like devoted monks mixed with suited G-Men, making them ideal as evil henchmen. The true scale of their evil, happening in the dark and perilous north, hasn’t yet been revealed; but judging by Coulter's increased venom, it won't be lollipops and sunshine for her Gobbled children. Wilson continues to perform like a terrifying, primal creature — to the extent that her horrible golden monkey daemon acts more human than she does.
The theme of the importance of truth and free-thinking flows through the veins of this episode; it’s effectively the lifeblood of the whole series. At the start, Lyra (Dafne Keen) wakes up in the back of a van — caught like a netted fish — before being rescued by Tony Costa (Daniel Frogson), who takes her to his fellow Gyptians.
Lyra (Dafne Keen) escapes with the Gyptians
In their nearby boat-homes, she learns more about the alethiometer, the golden compass that The Master (Clarke Peters) claimed ‘tells the truth’. The truth is a valuable commodity in this world of theocratic control and, though conceived before the eponymous fake news era, can't help but connect with the present state of the world.
As even more revelations befall Lyra, she has some genuinely touching discussions with Farder Coram (James Cosmo) about the nature of daemons. With wonderful, poetic confidence, Thorne’s dialogue delves into the psychological and metaphysical upshots involved in growing up. For a series named after a line in John Milton’s epic poem Paradise Lost, this only feels appropriate.
More than that, His Dark Materials is poetry and philosophy wrapped in the thrills and tears of an immersive fantasy story; an epic in its own right. This show gets better week by week, and this critic never wants it to end.
His Dark Materials continues Sundays at 8pm on BBC One
TRY CULTURE WHISPER
Receive free tickets & insider tips to unlock the best of London — direct to your inbox
| What | His Dark Materials, BBC One, episode 3 review |
| When |
17 Nov 19 – 17 Nov 20, 8:00 PM – 9:00 PM |
| Price | £n/a |
| Website | Click here for more information |