Collateral episode four review
A bittersweet end to David Hare's ambitious but over-complicated state of the nation drama
BBC Collateral episode four
'Did you get what you wanted?' DI Kip Glaspie's phantom husband is on speakerphone. His pregnant wife, busy driving herself home after three sleepless days replies: 'I got close'. The question could well have been asked of the viewing public. Did we get what we wanted? Sigh. We got close.
Across four one-hour episodes David Hare drew us a tense, intelligent, searing cop case that – let's be honest – just desperately wanted to be a political drama instead and took on too much.
Collateral was marketed as a 'state of the nation' drama, but where National Treasure examined the state of our nation by writing a plot about celebrity rape cases, Collateral examined the state of our nation in the periphery stories, surrounding the main drama. There were too many lectures, too many loose ends and not enough Billie Piper.
Collateral attempted to take in two murders, the role of a secret M15 undercover agent, PTSD, an international people-smuggling ring, corruption within the British armed forces, sexual-violence, abuse in the work place, the corrosive nature of British people's inability to express emotions, low-level drug dealing, the shadow cabinet and our entire foreign policy. A bit too much to manage in a four-part cop-show.
There wasn't really enough time for detective work, or satisfactory story arcs. Carey Mulligan's DI Glaspie conned Fatima and Mona Asif into giving her information about the people-smugglers in exchange for British residency. After that, it was more or less a question of finding them.
Glaspie was in trouble for offering residency, but nothing came of it in the end, when John Heffernan, M15's Sam Spence, proved to be an excellent villain puffed up on the self-righteous belief that preventing terrorists from coming into the UK mattered more than people-smuggling.
Shadow transport secretary David Mars (John Simm)'s entire narrative seemed surplus. Great, he grew a backbone and decided to leave his estranged wife Karen (the magnificent Billie Piper) and ditch the Labour party while he was at it – presumably because neither would behave exactly as he'd like them to. But, so what? Nothing came of his having accidentally helped an illegal immigrant stay in the UK, or of his posturing, or political ambitions.
Jane Oliver (Nicola Walker) picked the church over her girlfriend Linh (Kae Alexander), which was sad and poignant, and proof that Hare can do 'show not tell' when he wants to.
Collateral began full of promise, and with some important and interesting things to say about the UK today. But it took on too much, and in the end, came close but no cigar.
Across four one-hour episodes David Hare drew us a tense, intelligent, searing cop case that – let's be honest – just desperately wanted to be a political drama instead and took on too much.
Collateral was marketed as a 'state of the nation' drama, but where National Treasure examined the state of our nation by writing a plot about celebrity rape cases, Collateral examined the state of our nation in the periphery stories, surrounding the main drama. There were too many lectures, too many loose ends and not enough Billie Piper.
Collateral attempted to take in two murders, the role of a secret M15 undercover agent, PTSD, an international people-smuggling ring, corruption within the British armed forces, sexual-violence, abuse in the work place, the corrosive nature of British people's inability to express emotions, low-level drug dealing, the shadow cabinet and our entire foreign policy. A bit too much to manage in a four-part cop-show.
There wasn't really enough time for detective work, or satisfactory story arcs. Carey Mulligan's DI Glaspie conned Fatima and Mona Asif into giving her information about the people-smugglers in exchange for British residency. After that, it was more or less a question of finding them.
Glaspie was in trouble for offering residency, but nothing came of it in the end, when John Heffernan, M15's Sam Spence, proved to be an excellent villain puffed up on the self-righteous belief that preventing terrorists from coming into the UK mattered more than people-smuggling.
Shadow transport secretary David Mars (John Simm)'s entire narrative seemed surplus. Great, he grew a backbone and decided to leave his estranged wife Karen (the magnificent Billie Piper) and ditch the Labour party while he was at it – presumably because neither would behave exactly as he'd like them to. But, so what? Nothing came of his having accidentally helped an illegal immigrant stay in the UK, or of his posturing, or political ambitions.
Jane Oliver (Nicola Walker) picked the church over her girlfriend Linh (Kae Alexander), which was sad and poignant, and proof that Hare can do 'show not tell' when he wants to.
Collateral began full of promise, and with some important and interesting things to say about the UK today. But it took on too much, and in the end, came close but no cigar.
TRY CULTURE WHISPER
Receive free tickets & insider tips to unlock the best of London — direct to your inbox
| What | Collateral episode four review |
| Where | BBC Two, BBC Two , BBC Two , BBC Two | MAP |
| When |
05 Mar 18 – 30 Jun 18, Collateral episode 4 airs Monday 5 March 9pm |
| Price | £n/a |
| Website |